The true danger of the FBI raid on Attorney Michael Cohen

Good piece by Mr. Alan Dershowitz. Attorney-client privilege is a sacred constitutional right, the violation of which should concern us all regardless of our political predisposition. There are three Amendments to the Bill of Rights that have been violated here. Do you understand what they are and the real impact of the FBI’s actions? You should really read this explanation by Mr. Dershowitz, a renowned attorney, and Constitutional scholar.

As Written By Alan Dershowitz for Fox News:

Many TV pundits are telling viewers not to worry about the government’s intrusion into possible lawyer-client privileged communications between President Trump and his lawyer, Michael Cohen.

The pundits say that since prosecutors won’t get to see or use any privileged material taken when FBI agents raided and searched Cohen’s law office, home and hotel room Monday the intrusion will not be a problem. This is because prosecutors and FBI agents create firewalls and taint teams to preclude privileged information from being used against the client in a criminal case.

But this analysis completely misses the point and ignores the distinction between the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution on the one hand, and the Fourth and Sixth Amendments on the other.

The Fifth Amendment is an exclusionary rule. By its terms, it prevents material obtained in violation of the privilege of self-incrimination from being used to incriminate a defendant – that is, to convict him or her of a crime.

But the Fourth and Sixth Amendments provide far broader protections: they prohibit government officials from in any way intruding on the privacy of lawyer-client confidential rights of citizens.

In other words, if the government improperly seizes private or privileged material, the violation has already occurred, even if the government never uses the material from the…..


Alan Dershowitz: Why the FBI raid on Trump’s lawyer hurts all of us | Fox News


Leave a Comment

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse.